Motorways are the arteries of modern transportation, keeping goods and people moving efficiently. But what happens when those arteries become clogged? In the UK, the solution has been the adoption of smart motorways, designed to manage traffic flow dynamically. These systems adjust speed limits, open or close lanes, and respond to changing conditions in real-time, aiming to reduce congestion and improve safety without the need for costly infrastructure expansions.
However, despite their promise, these systems have faced growing criticism, particularly regarding driver safety, human error, and the risks of distracted driving. So, are these modern approaches to road management the future of transportation, or a high-risk gamble that compromises safety?
What are smart motorways?
Smart motorways are managed by National Highways in the UK and use technology to improve how traffic flows on the road. These systems can adjust speed limits in real time, close lanes during incidents, and convert the hard shoulder into a live running lane when needed—all designed to ease congestion and keep traffic moving efficiently.
The role of human error & distracted driving
Even with advanced technologies in place, motorway safety still hinges on driver behaviour. According to the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (RoSPA) over 90% of road accidents are caused by human error, regardless of whether the road is equipped with smart motorway systems or not. Key factors include:
- Distracted driving: Mobile phone use remains a leading cause of motorway collisions. Despite stricter laws, many drivers admit to using their phones behind the wheel, creating dangerous situations.
- Delayed reaction times: Without a hard shoulder, breakdowns in live lanes require immediate attention from other drivers. However, reaction times are significantly delayed when travelling at high speeds and when drivers are distracted.
- Lack of awareness: Many drivers do not fully understand how dynamic traffic management works, leading to confusion when lanes close or speed limits change unexpectedly.
Smart motorways rely on drivers responding quickly to digital road signs, lane closures, and speed changes. If a driver is distracted or slow to react, the risk of accidents increases dramatically.
No hard shoulder: a safety net removed?
One of the most controversial aspects of smart motorways is the removal of the hard shoulder. Traditionally, the hard shoulder provided a safe area for broken-down vehicles. Without it, vehicles must stop in live traffic lanes, which increases the risk of collisions.
In parts of the UK, emergency refuge areas (ERAs) are placed at regular intervals to provide safer spaces for stranded vehicles. However, research indicates that drivers may not always have enough time to reach these areas, especially on high-speed routes. This creates a heightened risk of being struck by other vehicles, particularly in the presence of distracted driving.
While detection systems are designed to alert traffic control when vehicles stop in live lanes, response times can be slow, increasing the risk of collisions as drivers may not have enough time to react.
Are smart motorways less safe?
Governments argue that smart motorways are as safe, or even safer, than traditional roads, citing built-in safety measures such as:
- Stopped vehicle detection: Radar systems that detect stationary vehicles and alert traffic control.
- Dynamic lane closures: Digital signs that close lanes when hazards are detected.
- Emergency refuge areas: Designated spaces where vehicles can stop safely.
Despite these measures, studies have shown that detection technology can fail, leading to delays in closing lanes. In some cases, it can take several minutes before the system detects a stationary vehicle, increasing the risk of a serious collision in the interim.
Serious incidents on the rise
While safety measures like stopped vehicle detection and dynamic lane closures are built into smart motorways, reports show an increase in incidents, particularly where the hard shoulder has been removed. Research also highlights that distracted driving, a key contributor to motorway collisions, continues to be a major safety concern. In 2022, 22 fatalities and 652 injuries occurred in Great Britain as a result of drivers using mobile phones while behind the wheel—underscoring the need for more robust driver awareness solutions.
The role of driver monitoring systems
Given the significant role distracted driving plays in motorway incidents, driver monitoring systems are an increasingly valuable tool in improving road safety. Using in-cab cameras and AI, these systems can identify when a driver is using a mobile phone, losing focus, or showing signs of fatigue—prompting alerts that help prevent incidents before they occur.
On roads where the hard shoulder has been removed, and where quick reactions are critical, this kind of real-time driver feedback can make a meaningful difference. By helping drivers stay focused, these systems complement smart motorway technologies and provide an added layer of safety.
Looking ahead: the future of smart motorways
As the debate around smart motorways intensifies, the future of these systems depends on addressing growing concerns. In the UK, the development of new smart motorways has slowed as authorities re-evaluate safety concerns.
Around the world, similar systems are being explored, with varying results. It’s clear that as technology continues to advance, a balanced approach that incorporates both innovation and driver education will be key to ensuring safety.
So, are smart motorways a good idea or a bad idea?
Smart motorways undoubtedly offer significant benefits in terms of congestion management and traffic flow. However, safety concerns remain, particularly as these systems rely heavily on driver awareness and quick reactions to changing road conditions.
To ensure the effectiveness of smart motorways, it’s crucial that we continue to educate drivers, enforce safe driving habits, and develop more reliable safety technologies. Only through a combined approach can we ensure that smart motorways truly enhance safety for everyone on the road.
Spanish 
English